APRIL
2002


SHOW ME THE MONEY!
 

Background

The Business Immigration Program - comprised of the Immigrant Investor Program (IIP), Entrepreneur Program and Self-Employed Program has, with a few exceptions, remained largely unchanged since the Immigration Regulations, 1978 came into effect.

The Auditor General for Canada has noted that the business definitions of those three programs were "vague and therefore difficult to apply" and suggested amendments be made to the selection criteria in order "to make them conducive to a rigorous selection of economic immigrants and the achievement of the Program’s objectives."

Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) has perceived that the subjectivity element in the existing definitions for Investors, Entrepreneurs and Self-Employed Persons has resulted in disputes as to their application and excessive challenges to selection decisions in the Federal Court. In addition, CIC was of the view that economic development has been compromised by the increasing use of the Self-Employed Program by applicants who do not meet the selection criteria for Skilled Workers, but are unwilling to make the requisite investment under the IIP or the Entrepreneur Program.

The purposes of the new provisions relating to business immigrants contained in the first set of proposed Regulations to the new Immigration and Refugee Protection Act ("Act") dated December 15, 2001, include providing "a clear and transparent statement of program requirements for both prospective business immigrants and officials involved in assessing applications" and simplifying "the assessment of business experience so as to arrive at selection decisions that are both consistent and objective".

The proposed Regulations will, for the first time, establish a selection grid which sets forth additional criteria to be applied in assessing business immigrant applications (see grid on p.4).

Proposed Changes

The following are highlights of the proposed changes:

Investors and Entrepreneurs

  • The most dramatic change is the introduction of an objective standard for business experience for both of these two categories. The new definition of business experience requires either: (1) ownership of a qualifying business of a minimum size ("Qualifying Business"); or (2) management of a business or a portion of a business with at least 50 employees. Investors and entrepreneurs who apply under the first option will be required to provide documentary evidence that, in any two of the past five years, they owned a Qualifying Business that meets any two of the four attributes in the following chart:

         OWNERSHIP
ATTRIBUTE 100% 50% 20%
EMPLOYMENT 2 4 10
SALES ($) 500 000 1 000 000 2 500 000
NET INCOME ($) 50 000 100 000 250 000
EQUITY ($) 125 000 250 000 625 000

Investors

  • The present net worth of $800,000 remains unchanged.

  • The requirement that the net worth be attained through the Investor’s own endeavours is removed.

  • The assets of the applicant’s spouse may be pooled with those of applicant in calculating net worth.

Entrepreneurs

  • A net worth requirement of $300,000 is introduced for the first time.

  • The requirement to meet certain conditions after landing is retained. However, in order to remove those conditions, Entrepreneurs will be required to provide documentation that, for a period of a least one year within the three year period after landing, they owned and managed a "Qualifying Canadian Business" that meets any two of four defined requirements for jobs, sales, net income and equity.

  • The requirements to create at least one full-time job for a person other than the applicant and his/her dependants and to provide active and ongoing participation in the management of the business have been retained.

Self-Employed Persons

  • Will be evaluated against a similar selection points grid as that applicable to Investors and Entrepreneurs, but modified to reflect the selection criteria applicable to their circumstances.

  • The new definition would include foreign nationals who have the intention and ability to create their own employment by making a significant contribution to the cultural or artistic life of Canada or to athletics in Canada at the world-class level.

Implementation Date

Consultations on the first set of proposed regulations containing selection, enforcement, refugees and the selection transition provisions ended on
February 13, 2002.

A second and final set of proposed regulations was prepublished in Part One of the Canada Gazette on March 9, 2002. The deadline for comments on this second set of proposed regulations, which relate to fees, loans, debt collection, seizures, transportation companies and transitional provisions, is April 8, 2002.

Denis Coderre, the Minister of Citizenship and Immigration Canada, has asked the House of Commons Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration to present their recommendations on the first set of proposed regulations by March 15, 2002, and on the second set by April 8, 2002. In a News Release dated March 8, 2002, the Minister reiterated that the target date for implementation of the Act is June 28, 2002.
  

NEXUS TO REPLACE PACE/CANPASS TO BENEFIT COMMUTERS

Since the terrorists attacks of September 11, 2001, the PACE and CANPASS dedicated commuter lanes at the various British Columbia-Washington State border crossings have been closed indefinitely. Replacing the PACE and CANPASS programs will be the NEXUS program, which has been operated on a trial basis at the Port Huron, Michigan Blue Water Bridge border crossing since November 2000.

Very similar to the PACE and CANPASS programs, the NEXUS program will allow the participants to enjoy a simplified entry process into the United States and Canada. The NEXUS program will offer substantially greater border security because all participants are required to undergo a vigorous screening process in advance, and their backgrounds are carefully examined by both the U.S. and Canadian Immigration officials prior to being accepted into the program. In contrast to the PACE and CANPASS program, however, each person wishing to apply for the NEXUS program benefits will need to fill out an application, regardless of age. There will be no application process for families and each applicant will be processed and interviewed independently.

Initial plans are for Canadian agencies to process the NEXUS applications first and handle the distribution of the application fee of CAD$50 for each application. Once the Canadian agencies approve an application, it will go to the U.S. enrolment centre at the Pacific Highway Truck Crossing, where the INS will do their own evaluation and criminal background check on the applicant. When an applicant clears the preliminary checks, an interview will be set up, most likely at the Pacific Highway Truck Crossing enrolment centre.

The INS hopes that the whole NEXUS system will be up and running by the end of June, 2002. The biggest hurdle right now is to get the enrolment process rolling. Because the INS expects hundreds of applications to flood in once the enrolment process begins, it is now in the process of expanding the enrolment centre and upgrading the software systems. The enrolment will first be open to Point Roberts residents only. After that, another group, such as previous PACE participants, may be considered. Once the enrolment is underway, the actual NEXUS inspection lanes installation should not take much time. It is estimated that the lane equipment could be finished in 3 days once there are enough people enrolled in the Program. Before the NEXUS automated card reading radio frequency antennas are installed, NEXUS participants will manually present their NEXUS cards at the dedicated inspection lanes.
 

EMPLOYMENT AUTHORIZATIONS FOR SPOUSES OF FOREIGN WORKERS

On November 30, 2001, Citizenship and Immigration Canada ("CIC") announced that the "Spousal Pilot Project" would become a permanent program. At the same time, some significant changes were made to this program. The Spousal Pilot Project allows the spouses of highly skilled people coming to Canada as temporary workers to be authorized to work without being subject to the same preliminary rigors as most other foreign workers.

History

The Spousal Pilot Project commenced on October, 1998. The implementation of the Spousal Pilot Project was driven by CIC's realization that, in order for Canadian employers to attract skilled foreign workers to Canada, it would be necessary to permit their spouses to also obtain employment in Canada without as much difficulty as that faced by a typical foreign worker.

In order for most foreign workers to obtain an Employment Authorization to work in Canada, their prospective Canadian employer must first approach Human Resources Development Canada ("HRDC") for the purpose of obtaining Labour Market Validation ("Employment Validation"). The process of obtaining Employment Validation normally requires an assessment of the existing job market and the likely effect of permitting the foreign worker into the Canadian labour force. Depending on the skill set, experience and qualifications of the individual, in many cases it is difficult or impossible for the accompanying spouse of a skilled foreign worker to satisfy the Employment Validation process.

Given that the cost of living in Canada requires a dual income for many people, the result was that a number of skilled foreign workers were forced to decline offers of employment in Canada. The Spousal Pilot Project therefore came into being to enable spouses of skilled foreign workers to obtain an Employment Authorization, without being subjected to the normal Employment Validation process.

Recent Changes

The November, 2001 announcement by CIC included a number of changes. First and foremost, the temporary Spousal Pilot Project is now a permanent program of CIC.

CIC has also expanded the category of workers ("primary workers") whose spouses will now qualify under this Program. The list of occupations for the primary worker now include a number of technical and skilled trades, in addition to the previous job categories which are generally in the managerial and professional area.

Another change is that an accompanying spouse is now able to apply for an open (i.e. not job-specific) Employment Authorization at the time they first enter Canada. The accompanying spouse can also apply at a later date for an open Employment Authorization within Canada. The benefit of applying at the time the accompanying spouse enters Canada is that they will not encounter the same delay that they will if they apply later on from within Canada. This delay can often lead to difficulties in arranging the start date for their employment, which in turn can lead to losing a prospective job or, at the very least, frustration for both employer and employee.

Another significant change to this program is that, consistent with Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the provisions of this program are now available not only to persons filling the traditional definition of a "spouse". This program is now open to persons who are considered to be common-law partners. A common-law partner is being defined as a person who is cohabiting in a conjugal relationship with another person, having so cohabited for a period of at least one year. Common-law partners also include same sex partners.

Effect of Recent Changes

As before, the primary benefit of the Spousal Pilot Project is that it enables Canadian employers to be more competitive in the search for talented foreign workers. The benefit of the recent changes is that the Spousal Pilot Project now applies to the spouses of a broader range of skilled foreign workers, which will hopefully enhance Canada's competitiveness in the global pursuit of human capital.  
 

TRANSITIONAL PROVISIONS FOR THE ECONOMIC CLASS OF IMMIGRANTS: TO APPLY OR NOT?

The new Immigration Act and Refugee Act (“IRPA”) received royal assent on November 1, 2001 and is scheduled to come into effect on June 28, 2002. Two sets of proposed regulations setting out in detail the procedures needed to administer the new Act were published in the Canada Gazette on December 15, 2001 and March 9, 2002. The first set of proposed regulations addressed selection, enforcement, refugees and the selection transition provisions. The second set of regulations related to seizures, loans, debt collection, transportation companies and transitional provisions.

Consultations with parliamentarians, provinces, territories and other interested parties on the proposed regulations have been ongoing since the pre-publication of the first set of regulations. This means that the proposed regulations are still a “work in progress” until the publication of the final regulations in the Canada Gazette, prior to the June 28, 2002 implementation date of the new Act.

The provisions dealing with transition in the first set of proposed regulations may be found at Part 16, ss. 259 and 260. The proposed transitional regulations published on December 15, 2001 dealt with the selection for “economic” classes of immigrants. The “economic” category of immigrants includes skilled worker (independent and assisted relatives) and business immigrants (entrepreneurs, investors, and self-employed).  The transitional regulations are extremely important, as a number of provisions in the new Act and regulations are to be applied “retroactively”.

In light of the negative feedback that Citizenship and Immigration Canada (“CIC”) received with respect to the proposed transitional provisions contained in the first set of regulations, the Honourable Mr. Denis Coderre, the Minister of CIC, amended the transitional regulations on February 26, 2002. The amendments had the effect of allowing more skilled workers to be assessed under the current selection grid until January 1, 2003.

The key dates to bear in mind are December 17, 2001 (the date of release of the first set of proposed regulations), June 28, 2002 (the date the new IRPA comes into effect), and January 1, 2003 (for federal independent/skilled worker cases).

The transitional regulations for economic classes are as follows:

(1)  The transitional regulations apply to all applications submitted prior to June 28, 2002 in the skilled worker (independent and assisted relative) and business (entrepreneur, investor, and self-employed) categories.

(2)  All economic class applicants who receive a “selection decision” prior to June 28, 2002 will continue to be processed to finalization under the current regulations.

A “selection decision” refers to the visa officer’s assessment in determining whether the applicant meets the minimum number of points to qualify for immigration. The visa officer may render a refusal decision or a positive decision. This assessment would usually occur after paper screening, at interview or at the time that the visa officer has determined that the case warrants an interview waiver. The timing as to when the “selection decision” is made at CIC Overseas Missions will vary depending on such factors as specific administrative practices; the size of that mission’s “inventory/backlog” of cases; and whether additional checks are required.

(3)  Skilled Workers who applied before December 17, 2001:

(a)  who have not received a “selection decision” prior to June 28, 2002, will continue to be selected under the current selection criteria until January 1, 2003;

(b)    who have not received a “selection decision” prior to January 1, 2003, will be subject to the proposed selection criteria and the proposed pass mark of 70 points.

(4) Skilled Workers who applied after December 17, 2001 and have not received a “selection decision” by June 28, 2002, will be subject to the new proposed selection criteria and a pass mark yet to be determined. The proposed pass mark in the first set of pre-published regulations was 80 points. As of mid-April, 2002, CIC has only indicated that the pass mark will fall within the range of 71 to 79 points.

(5) Business Immigrants (Investors), who applied before April 1, 1999, and have signed any investor document (having made the investment under the federal or provincial provisions) before April 1, 1999, will be dealt with in accordance to the current selection criteria. Otherwise, one must refer to the transitional regulations described in (2) and (6) of this article.

(6)  Business Immigrants (Entrepreneurs, Investors, and Self-employed) who applied after December 17, 2001, and  have not received a “selection decision” prior to June 28, 2002, will be dealt with under the new proposed regulations. This has major ramifications given that the proposed regulations have made significant changes to the definitions of business applicants - entrepreneurs, investors and self-employed. (see “Show Me The Money!”, p.1)

In the latest proposed changes to the transitional regulations on February 26, 2002, the Minister of CIC has provided economic applicants (skilled workers and businesses) with the option to withdraw their applications and request a refund of the government processing fees. This provision only applies in limited circumstances where the application submitted has not as yet passed through the preliminary evaluation, referred to as “paper screening”. To initiate a refund, applicants must contact the CIC Overseas Mission where their application was submitted.

Applicants who have received a notice of waiver of interview, an invitation to an interview, a letter indicating that the interview will be scheduled at a future date, or instructions to undergo a medical examination are not eligible for the refund as their applications have already completed the “paper screening” process.

Applicants whose cases have been refused are also not eligible to apply for refund of the government processing fees.

Applicants whose cases have been refused or withdrawn, however, may apply for a refund of the Right of Landing Fees (“ROLF”), if these fees were previously paid to CIC.
 

IMMIGRATION LINES VIA EMAIL

If you would prefer to receive Immigration Lines via email, please send your name and e-mail address to webmaster@cwilson.com.  You may access back issues of this and other Clark Wilson newsletters on our website at www.cwilson.com.

 




Kenneth Ing
Tel. 604.643.3158
E. kki@cwilson.com



Ron McKay
Immigration Consultant
Tel. 604.643.3148
E. rem@cwilson.com



Neil Melliship
Tel. 604.643.3154
E. npm@cwilson.com



Larry Yen
Tel. 604.891.7715
E. lky@cwilson.com

800.885 West Georgia Street
Vancouver, BC  Canada  V6C 3H1
Tel. 604.687.5700
Fax. 604.687.6314

Questions or Comments?

For more information on any article contained in this issue of Clark Wilson’s Immigration Lines or on any Immigration matter, please contact any member of our Immigration Group.

Immigration Group 
Members
Lawyer Direct Telephone
& Email Info
Kenneth Ing T. 604.643.3158
kki@cwilson.com
Neil Melliship T. 604.643.3154
npm@cwilson.com
Larry Yen T. 604.891.7715
lky@cwilson.com
Immigration Consultant
Ron McKay T. 604.643.3148
rem@cwilson.com
Clark Wilson's Immigration Lines is published periodically by the Immigration Group at Clark Wilson LLP. The information contained in
this newsletter should not be treated by readers as legal advice and ought not to be relied on without specific legal counsel being sought. 
Editor: Kenneth Ing © 2002, Clark Wilson LLP. All Rights Reserved.